In defense of e-books and e-readers

Sorry, I slacked off again.

I have a Kindle, I’m sure I’ve mentioned it before. I’ve had it for about two years now, and I love it. I’ve got probably 300+ books on it, and yes I admit, the largest number (188) is under Romance. I like to check out the competition. That’s not exactly true, although I do like to see how other writers write romances, what themes they use, how they treat their characters, etc. I think when you write, you can always learn by reading.

A frustrating thing about discussing, or trying to, e-readers and e-books are those people who then say, “Oh, I’d never do that. I like books too much.” They then go on to talk about how they love the smell of books, or the feel of the paper as they turn the page — and they say this as though I don’t.

I understand the resistance to technology. I remember not having a cell phone as it was becoming more common, and my own feeling at the time, which I know I stated, was: “I don’t want to be that accessible.” Which was funny, because it wasn’t as though I was inaccessible back then. I worked and went home and went out occasionally, and often alone, but it wasn’t like I had huge gaps of time where I was unavailable. When I was needed by my office outside of the usual hours, it was usually in the middle of the night and guess who was plenty accessible right about then?

Because I love to read, I didn’t have that initial resistance to the idea of an e-reader. In fact, mostly I thought it’d be so cool to have something like that and not have to carry physical books around. I have some tendonitis-type and repetitive motion issues with my arms and wrists from time to time, so I thought the idea of a small device with lots of books was a terrific idea. It is handy to be able to read a book like War and Peace that would be heavy and/or hard to hold open — and hence tire your hands — on a light device like a Kindle.

And let me say I do love paper books. Getting an e-reader did not mean that I was going to suddenly replace my collection of stuff and toss it all. It’s attractive in a space-saving sense but I’m not going to do it. I have sentimental attractions to books like anyone else. I still have this wonderful box of books by Michael Moorcock, Clifford Simak and Samuel R. Delaney that I found at a library when I was in high school. I think I gave them $5 for the box and it was a steal. I still buy paper books, too; the most recent were the final two Redwall books by Brian Jacques. I also snagged something like twenty-two Agatha Christie novels from my current library off the free table.

So let’s all stipulate that you can like books on e-readers and books on paper. One does not preclude the other nor does it have to.

Isn’t the important thing the content? Does it matter if I’m reading the latest bestseller on paper or e-ink? I don’t think so — I’m all about the content, and if it can be delivered comfortably over an e-reader, then I’m all for it. It’s less strain on my hands and arms and it’s easier to carry the Kindle around.

Are there drawbacks? Sure. First off, it’s difficult if not impossible to lend an e-book. Some books have a “lend me” attribute, and if you do it, you can’t read it yourself while your friend is borrowing it. Your other option is then to lend the physical e-reader and then you can’t read anything. So I’m not saying e-readers are perfect. I’m saying they are a nice, convenient option for those who want them.

A second problem is e-book pricing. I am baffled when I see an e-book that costs more than the print version. I suspect many people want e-books to be free, or close to it, and that’s not right. People spend a lot of time writing stories and if you want to keep it, you should compensate them. Otherwise, go to the library. (I feel the same about music.) If an author wants to offer a free book, I think that’s great, and I admit that most of what’s on my Kindle is free. I’d buy more if I could, but right now I can’t.

I think this will all settle out although I can’t guess how long it will take. The music industry is facing similar issues and is adjusting, if slowly. The movie industry as well. I hope it settles out fairly for all concerned, because I hardly think e-readers are going away.

6 responses to this post.

  1. I absolutely love my Kindle. I bought it for “research” but it’s become my primary go-to for fiction. There’s instant gratification and, quite honestly, I’m enjoying new authors who are only e-published for much less money than I used to spend on paper books. Not that I don’t buy paper books. I buy LOTS of paper books and especially enjoy having paper copies of books by my favorite authors. I attend book signings and conventions and get autographs, too. A person’s love of reading isn’t tethered to devices and formats. It’s anchored by the words and the experience of being transported into the story.


  2. I like books too. But I have small children who rip them. Most of my paper books are packed away safely in the attic. I have a few on a shelf in my closet, to try to protect them.

    My reading time is when one of them is sleeping on me, leaving me with one hand. I can’t hold a book and flip pages like that. And the flipping wakes her up. Much easier to read on the Kindle for PC installed on my laptop. It holds the text up where I can see it, and I need just one finger for the right arrow key.


  3. Posted by Lady Falcon on September 13, 2012 at 10:55 am


    I have said I love my paper books and all that and I’ve told my adult daughter I didn’t want an e-reader but mostly because I didn’t think I’d use it all that much. I tend to read my existing books over and over because my favorite authors only publish a new one once or twice a year. (That is understandable – I’m not complaining.)

    Then there was my desire not to have her spending that much money on me. This was all two-three years a go and then I started buying some e-books of a couple of my favorite Lit authors. 🙂 We bought a small tablet and I started being able to read Lit on the couch. Which I love because now I’m in the same room as the family in the evening.

    So, now, I have been doing some research on the different e-readers to decide which one I want and then it’s going on my Christmas wish list for my husband to buy me. So far I’m leaning towards a kindle. I’ve d/l’d the app on my tablet and on my phone. Used it in fact to read some of the were-tiger series while at work on my phone by emailing myself the file. Boy, that was a nifty discovery.

    I look forward to owning one but, as you said, I’m not giving up my paper books and I will still buy the hardbacks for my favorite authors.


    • Posted by Lady Falcon on September 20, 2012 at 8:15 am

      My husband, daughter, and I were at lunch after church last Sunday. I mentioned in conversation that I’ve about talked myself into buying a Kindle. A couple hours later when we are in Wal-mart I go to find him in the store and he is in electronics buying me a Kindle. 🙂 I have an amazing hubby.

      So, I’ve had it less than a week and have been loving it. All I’ve downloaded so far are the free books but its kept me busy. Now I just need to get a case for it. I found some cute ones on Etsy.

      Just thought I’d give you all an update. lol


      • Yes, there are so many free books. Especially older ones. I’ve recently read a few of the classics that I had missed earlier in life.

  4. Posted by Jerry on September 19, 2012 at 11:26 pm

    I have a Sony 700 reader and love it! I take it with my for Doctor Appointments, Car servicing, etc, etc; 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: